Overview
How well do your friends and family know each other? Find out with this portable tin of 50 hypothetical scenarios!
Take turns pulling a card and reading each one out loud. Vote for which of you would be the most likely to find themselves in the fun, wacky, or maybe even slightly embarrassing scenarios. If a player gets the most votes, then the shoe fits and that player keeps the card.
Who would enter a hot dog eating contest?
Who would throw away their phone and go off the grid?
Who would start an Instagram for their cat?
Who would cry watching a Super Bowl commercial?
Who would try to contact aliens?
No matter what scenarios they end up with, the person with the most cards at the end of the game wins!
ENTERTAINING FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY: This cute, compact tin is filled with 50 scenarios sure to get friends and family of all ages laughing and reminiscing together.
GREAT GIFT OR STOCKING STUFFER: Perfect for families in need of game-night inspiration, dinner-party hosts and partygoers, or campers looking for a fun conversation game by the fire.
TAKE IT ANYWHERE: The petite, portable tins are the perfect size to throw in your backpack or luggage for a vacation.
EXPLORE THE ENTIRE SERIES: This game is part of the After Dinner Amusements series, a collection of tiny tins filled with prompts for lively conversation, trivia, icebreakers, and endless laughs.
Perfect for:
Take turns pulling a card and reading each one out loud. Vote for which of you would be the most likely to find themselves in the fun, wacky, or maybe even slightly embarrassing scenarios. If a player gets the most votes, then the shoe fits and that player keeps the card.
Who would enter a hot dog eating contest?
Who would throw away their phone and go off the grid?
Who would start an Instagram for their cat?
Who would cry watching a Super Bowl commercial?
Who would try to contact aliens?
No matter what scenarios they end up with, the person with the most cards at the end of the game wins!
ENTERTAINING FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY: This cute, compact tin is filled with 50 scenarios sure to get friends and family of all ages laughing and reminiscing together.
GREAT GIFT OR STOCKING STUFFER: Perfect for families in need of game-night inspiration, dinner-party hosts and partygoers, or campers looking for a fun conversation game by the fire.
TAKE IT ANYWHERE: The petite, portable tins are the perfect size to throw in your backpack or luggage for a vacation.
EXPLORE THE ENTIRE SERIES: This game is part of the After Dinner Amusements series, a collection of tiny tins filled with prompts for lively conversation, trivia, icebreakers, and endless laughs.
Perfect for:
- Party hosts and party goers
- Families looking for fun "offline" activities
While major retailers like Amazon may carry After Dinner Amusements: If the Shoe Fits, we specialize in bulk book sales and offer personalized service from our friendly, book-smart team based in Portland, Oregon. We’re proud to offer a Price Match Guarantee and a streamlined ordering experience from people who truly care.
We’re trusted by over 75,000 customers, many of whom return time and again. Want proof? Just check out our 25,000+ customer reviews—real feedback from people who love how we do business.
Prefer to talk to a real person? Our Book Specialists are here Monday–Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. PST and ready to help with your bulk order of After Dinner Amusements: If the Shoe Fits.